Kathryn Anne Edwards is a labor economist whose research focuses on labor markets, public policy, and inequality. She once worked for Rand, but now runs her own research business. In addition to her work as a researcher, Edwards also devotes time to communicating to the public on economic issues. She's a columnist for Bloomberg, an economic influencer on social media, and she's the co-founder of the Optimist Economy Media Company, which produces the Optimist Economy podcast.
Episode Description
The American economy is the largest in the world by nominal GDP. Generating about a quarter of the global economic output. But that can feel abstract or disconnected from everyday experience. For people who are struggling to get by, it doesn't matter how large the country's economy is, if they can’t pay their bills. One labor economist has been working for years trying to help people understand the lived realities of the American economy, as well as alternative solutions for the problems people face. That’s the focus of this episode of Stats and Stories with guest Kathryn Anne Edwards.
Full Transcript
Rosemary Pennington
The American economy is the largest in the world by nominal GDP, generating about a quarter of the globe's economic output. But that can feel abstract or disconnected from everyday experience for people who are struggling to get by. It doesn't matter how large the country's economy is if they can't pay their bills. One labor economist has been working for years to help people understand the lived realities of the American economy, as well as alternative solutions for the problems people face. That's the focus of this episode of Stats and Stories, where we explore the statistics behind the stories and the stories behind the statistics. I'm Rosemary Pennington. Stats and Stories is a production of the American Statistical Association in partnership with Miami University's Departments of Statistics and Media, Journalism, and Film. Joining me, as always, is co-host John Bailer, Emeritus Professor of Statistics at Miami University. Our guest today is Kathryn Ann Edwards. Edwards is a labor economist whose research focuses on labor markets, public policy, and inequality. She once worked for Rand, but now runs her own research business. In addition to her work as a researcher, Edwards also devotes time to communicating to the public on economic issues. She's a columnist for Bloomberg, an economic influencer on social media, and she's the co-founder of the Optimist Economy Media Company, which produces the Optimist Economy podcast, Kathryn. Thank you so much for joining us today.
Kathryn Edwards
Thank you all so much for having me.
Rosemary Pennington
You've been doing a lot of work in multiple spaces, including TikTok, which seems terrifying to me, to try to communicate about issues related to the economy and and and such. Why did you feel like communicating this information was so important.
Kathryn Edwards
Well, people deserve to know what's happening in the economy. They deserve to understand it, and I think if they if they understand it, they have the ability to ask for more, to demand a better performance, and not be you know kind of shushed in a way to say like, well, this is just how the economy works. You wouldn't understand. I think that as a profession, economists, we can be a little bit arrogant and obtuse at the same time, and really swat away people who don't understand as like, well, this is econ 101, you know. And I don't know if we necessarily take the time and the effort to explain to Americans, this is what's going on in your economy. So, it fills a public service role in my life. That's, you know, I have all this information and I have all this understanding. I ought to, you know, give it back.
John Bailer
So, what are some of the most difficult concepts to communicate about the about economics and policy to the general public.
Kathryn Edwards
Tough, yeah, that's tough. They can they they all have a degree of difficulty. I think it's. I think probably the hardest part is really just presenting the information in a way that you can get around people's strongly held priors, as an economist would say, is that it's less. This is something that's hard to understand, and more. I hold this thing really, really firmly to be the truth. And so, walking around that can be is the hardest part. And so, it's it's presenting the information in a way that is accurate, but also new and kind of can see where those you know deeply held priors are, but moving around them. And I, you know, to to, you know, get ahead of you a little bit, you know, it's it's it's held on the left and right. I think that people, you know, they want to. The other side's crazy, and I'm just smart. But when it comes to understanding the economy, there's a lot that people don't understand. A lot of things that they hold onto that you just really have to kind of carefully chip away at and say, you know, we understand this or this is the case. And I mean, I can give you some more examples, but it's I think that's the harder part.
Rosemary Pennington
Yeah, I would love to hear some of those examples if you have some handy.
Kathryn Edwards
Yeah. So okay. So you know, I will make a video about taxes, and I will almost every time get the comment, "All taxes are theft," and I will get the comment: "The most efficient use of taxes is to give it back to me." And it's it's getting a you know there's a real economic argument behind all of that, which is that if you think of the most productive use of a marginal dollar in the economy, you know there's a really good case to be made that it's not going to be the government. However, you know that marginal dollar question. Isn't the only one that comes into how do you design a tax system? So you could you you could argue like okay you know maybe a business or a consumer would be better off with $1 than the government. That said, like we have to build roads. We need schools. We need an educated populace. We need to have a clean environment. We you know we have services that are provided in a private market, and that private market is failing to deliver those services adequately. And the marginal dollar question doesn't really get at what is the infrastructure that our economy needs that tax dollars need to support. So trying to dance around the like, I get it. The everything the government does is wrong. It's always been wrong, and it's never been efficient. I will take back Medicare. You know, kind of like you don't like. I think the the the instinct is just to go petty and to tell people like actually you're stupid and you don't know what you're talking about. And so what I try really hard to do is just to expand the conversation to look, tax policy this century has been wielded as an indiscriminate weapon towards anything that's going wrong in the economy, and what we have learned is it doesn't do a good job. And even if you don't like taxes, I mean, who does? I don't like the government, and I like money. Of course, I don't like taxes, but like, I need things in my economy that private sector is not doing, and that I can't afford to do myself. So I I try to just you know fight the instinct to just immediately tell people they're wrong, and instead paint a broader and different picture that gives them a way out.
John Bailer
Do you do you see people kind of you know moving towards those those way outs that you've you defined? It sounds this is a a pretty difficult challenge. I mean, we see this in lots of different different conversations we've had over the years on this on this podcast. Is that you know when you're trying to convince someone about something and they they have these deeply held beliefs that they won't let go of. What what are some of the things purposely that you would do? You know how how do you address those the critique that you just mentioned, you know, like they should just give the money to me. Is it is it the all the infrastructure and things that you just mentioned, or what else do you do?
Kathryn Edwards
Helps to have a little bit of a straw man and illustration, you know, to to kind of prop up someone of like, look, y'all, like there are people out there who think that the only effective economic policy is the one that immediately benefits them, like, you know, is a road a good investment? Depends. Is it my street? If it's not my street, it's not a good investment. And like the fact that you want interstate commerce moving from like Wisconsin to Minnesota doesn't matter to them because they're in Southern California, and therefore anything that benefits somebody else is a bad investment, right? Like you've immediately created space for people where they're like, "Well, I don't want to be that guy. I don't. I don't want to be the person that thinks that." But that is essentially what is hiding behind, or what is like behind something like it's not my job to pay for somebody else's children. So telling them like, "Yeah, my guy. It actually kind of is your job. It doesn't work. But saying like making it about like you know doing the same thing but in a different setting and setting up this straw man of like the proverbial guy that hates that he lives in you know I'm in Texas so I can be like well the proverbial guy that hates that he has money in Texas that goes to like helping someone in Minnesota, like yeah, like he doesn't really like that he helps the national economy, but a strong national economy benefits him, and so you have to really you know like you have to understand that just because you are the center of your universe, you are not the center of the economy, and certain things have to happen in the economy that don't go directly through you. That doesn't mean they're not good. Like just because you person are not the target of the investment doesn't mean the investment is bad. We don't make economic decisions like that, and we can't because if we did that, we would just have you know gross corruption, an unbalanced economy where the richest people get whatever they want, and nobody wants that. We want a fair economy, and so we have to think about what is the best investment, not for the economy, and not as what is best investment for you guy who loves himself and not children. And so, kind of, you got to like kind of walk around the belief without necessarily saying like, "Listen, selfish person, it is your job to pay for somebody else's kids. I've made a couple videos about this, and one of the most popular comments is always like, "Why are you trying so hard to explain this? Like, it is your job to pay for other people's children. We live in a society, and I think, in fact, on one of these videos, a very famous and prominent New York Times columnist commented, 'We live in a society, people. So I felt like there was a little bit of people poking in front of me, of like, man, you're trying really hard to get someone on board with what should be a really simple declarative sentence. But that's kind of how I I try to approach it: is set up someone for them to not identify with, but but dislike almost in a way, and then that kind of. You're walking, taking a long walk around.
Rosemary Pennington
There often is negative sentiment around the economy, around taxes, and you have this media company that you have called Optimist Economy, and your podcast is Optimist Economy. Why have you chosen that framing for this?
Kathryn Edwards
Two reasons, really. One practical, one philosophical. So the practical reason is, you know, I'm a PhD economist, and I have a read of economic research and the policy and evidence base that the vast majority of Americans aren't aware of. And my reason for optimism is that we have demonstrated in so many communities across the U.S. that we can have better public policy that lifts up families, lifts up workers, and makes for a stronger economy. I think you've got, you know, you've got they've got really good standard heirs too, right? But that bringing that to Americans is really about showing them how much we haven't tried, and so the the mantra of the show is sometimes all you need for optimism is just a really low bar, and the federal government over the past 25 years is a low bar of the problems that households are really struggling with that we know two states over really helped, but the federal government isn't doing it. And so the the show is really trying to explain, like, oh yeah, we can have childcare, and more people would work, and families would make a lot more income, and children would do better in school. But like, only certain localities have decided to do that, and the federal government knows for a fact that almost every family with a kid under five would have higher income if the childcare was free, and this would do a lot for things like poverty and program participation. And they're not doing it. So optimism comes from the fact that they, the federal government, has tried so little, and yet states and localities have shown how much we can do. The philosophical component is really just spite. I've said this previously. Like I just don't like being a pessimist and giving not a pessimist so much as giving up, like being a cynic and giving up. That's permission to not try. Like, well, things will never change. Great, you just told every member of Congress that they don't need to bother because you you don't think it'll happen, so they don't need to prove you wrong. So I think I I just optimism is like white knuckled, you know, just grinding those teeth of like we can do better, and I do not care what you say. I will never give up in thinking we can do better, and that holds you know thinking we can do better is a very high standard for Congress to meet, and so I wouldn't give him a lower one.
Rosemary Pennington
You're listening to Stats and Stories, and we're talking about communicating economics with Kathryn Ann Edwards. So you have a you're a PhD economist. You're a labor economist, I guess. For our people who don't know what that does, what what what a labor economist does, could you explain the kind of research that you do, or or that you're drawn to, and what kinds of things a labor economist might be measuring?
Kathryn Edwards
Oh, sure. So the profession of economics with a you know with a PhD has lots of different factions, and they're looking at different they're looking at different things, right? The is it theoretical or is it more empirical? Looking at data in the world versus you know, equations that do a good job at predicting how the world works, and then there's the subject: what are you looking at, and who are you looking at? So one of the way easiest ways to understand the division of economics is that there's three main groups. There's the people who look at firms; that's industrial organization. There's the people that look at governments. That's public economics, and then there's the people that look at workers. That's labor economics, and so they're all going to bleed together because workers work at firms, and everybody's affected by public policy. But I look at workers, and that was my kind of north star going through school. Labor and public. I mean, that was my concentration, but a labor economist.
John Bailer
So, when you when you look at the at labor and its con and labor's contribution, there's, as you described it, the the economic system is incredibly complex and very difficult, and it's a challenge to communicate, which which you've spent a most recent years focusing on. How do you think about and how do you describe the impact of labor on the economy? I mean, sort of what's the what's the role of worker here? It's you know, and and some of your pod your podcasts I've listened to and some of your other interviews that I've listened to, you know, you you've often talked about sort of these very high level changes. We need to change. If if you want to see if we're seeing a recession, we need to change this rate, or we need to change this part of the tax code. But it doesn't. It's not. It tends not to be drilling down to kind of the workers' impact on what what's happening within the economy. So how how is am I off base here or? Are there things that need that are important to clarify?
Kathryn Edwards
So the the market the labor market is you know it's a market. I mean there's there's markets for goods, there's markets for services, and there's the market for labor. And so the study of of the labor market is going to get at some pretty fundamental questions: Are is this market producing enough jobs for the workers in the U.S. that want them? Is this market producing enough income for the workers who are employed in those jobs, and is this market, you know, functioning on a basic level of providing of like matching workers to employers? So there's this this this notion of you know performance related to the number of jobs. There's this notion of performance related to the amount of income, you know, kind of getting to workers, and then there's this idea of almost like efficiency and matching. So, do we have the right workers? Do the workers have jobs? Are the workers making money? All of that can be seen through an individual perspective of like, do I have a job? Am I making money? Is this job a job I'm qualified for? And then you can kind of zoom back up and go to the market perspective of is the market producing these things, and you know what is really I think fascinating to me about labor economics is that everybody experiences that first person, and then the question is, does the big data reflect that, and is the big data this macro data is it showing us something is wrong, even though people themselves are saying they are wrong. And so, when in recessions, in times of crises, you get you get all kinds of problems showing up in the labor market because of the the way people work, the way people earn money. One of the biggest problems is that, like this, one of the biggest problems is that the labor market is. You can think of it like you turn over your watch, and you see all the gears on the back, and it's just like, and all these all these gears are turning. And the faster the gears turn, the more mobility workers have, the more they move from job to job. And every job you get tends to be a raise, and every job you get, you tend to learn something. When mobility slows down, people get really stuck, and it's to me, mobility is where macro and micro come together. You know, it's not just it's the dynamic aspect is not how many jobs do you have and what are they earning, but how how much are people moving through the market. The biggest weakness of the U.S. labor market, really, of the past 40 years is that that gear has been slowing down due to employer concentration, and you just people don't have as many employers to go to when they're looking for a job. I I came up with the example of the consulting firms or the accounting firms. There used to be like the Big 10 or the big eight, and now there's like the big two, but and all their names are just like a series of nouns, like a really long set of nouns pushed together. That the you know consolidation of the labor market is giving workers fewer options. I don't know if that really answered your question per se. I I think the other perspective to look at it is where is this market failing as a market, and then where is this market failing as the means to an end, which is the end is we want Americans to have money and be happy, and they do a job and then they get to do that, and so there's there's this whole idea of like market mechanics, how is this market functioning? People are buying, and you know, you're buying and selling labor. How is that going? Versus, this is a democracy, and we value having things like, you know, not having gross income inequality, and having people who work, you know, be rewarded with a life that they can afford, that's decent. The labor market is the way of doing that. I mean, it is the way to get Americans money.
Kathryn Edwards
You know, if you are thinking about a middle class, it is a middle class the labor market has produced. If you are thinking about a working class that still gets to participate in the U.S. economy, that is something the labor market produces. And so you can think about the market mechanics of how it's performing, and of course, the means to the end of like, are we reaching the end that the labor market is supposed to be giving us?
Rosemary Pennington
As you were talking, I don't know that I have seen this lack of mobility covered as well as it might have been by American news media. It feels like they often get trapped in the. Of the you know the job numbers and and are Americans satisfied or dissatisfied with this idea that over 40 years that ability to be mobile which is sort of the fuel of the American dream has sort of become stagnated I feel like has been undercovered again from my own perspective and I wonder are there other stories of the American economy that you think have been undercovered that we need to be paying closer attention to.
Kathryn Edwards
Okay, all right. Well, these are both going to be super liberal, but I'll think of I'll if I have time, I'll do a conservative one. But the the first is that when we cover when the news media covers tax policy, they they over they put way too much weight on changes to tax rates. When what has really gutted the efficiency and effectiveness of the tax system is the number of coupons we give out. So this would be every credit, every deduction, every adjustment. There are 271 of them, and if you were to combine them into a spending program, they would be almost twice the size of Social Security. I mean, they are massive. This is a massive amount of spending. We're like, okay, you made $100,000. Here are the brackets. Here is the marginal rates, and here is what you owe. But you don't end up paying that because you apply all your coupons and you end up with the difference between what you were going to owe and what you paid. That is tax expenditure. Conservatives hate this notion of tax expenditure because it's like tax theft. It's my money. You can't spend money, my money on me. However, this public, if this were a public program, it would be the largest one, larger than Social Security. If this were a public program, all of these things would be evaluated. If I spend money as the federal government on food stamps, every state has to give me back data: who got it, whether the fraud rates, when did it come back, who we have evaluations, we have performance reviews. Like money that is spent as spending is evaluated. Money that is spent through the tax code goes into a black hole and it's up on PhD researchers trying to get tenure to figure out what happened to it. That is not good, especially given how much money it is. So I think the the media has has almost like turn not turned a blind eye, but underappreciated just how much of our economy, of our federal economy, our this debt and budget problem we have is wrapped up in the way that our tax system has become a complex bonus mechanism. Oh, we we like you, and I'm not polling well with the working class, so now there's no tax on tips, or I'm not polling well, and you know old people don't like taxes on social security, so we're going to give a credit for it. And this is gutting our tax system and making it incomprehensible. So one of the things that I've talked about previously is there is a reason why tax preparation and accounting services are one of the fastest growing prices in the economy, and it is very possible that it is so complicated for you to prepare your tax return that you will pay more to prepare taxes than you will get back in the credit that Congress designated for you. So I think that's underappreciated and needs to be talked about a lot more because we can't get over we can't get over the budget issues we have unless we tackle this. So that's one. I think the second issue that is underappreciated is the way in which our regulations of the labor market have taken us backwards in time. So the minimum wage not being raised, I think, is really salient. People understand that 7.25 is abysmally low, embarrassing for a lot of people to think about. Yes, lots of states have gone higher, but when you think of things like overtime protection, things like how easy is it to join a labor union, we kind of get told history in chronological order of like, well, there was the New Deal, and then we got labor rights, and we can organize, and we can we have, you know, the Fair Labor Standards Act, and employers can't treat people too poorly. Those two pieces of legislation have been gutted, eviscerated in either enforcement or in practice. There is a multi-billion-dollar industry dedicated to preventing people from organizing, as is their right in a union. And so, what I always find really shocking is when I tell people that we live closer, like our economy now looks closer to the 1920s than I think people really understand. We are in a period of apex economic inequality in terms of wages and income.
Kathryn Edwards
We're not as bad on wealth, but that's because a lot of people in the middle class own houses. But yeah, we we we've hit so many markers that would put us back in the 1920s in terms of the rights of workers, the earnings of workers, and I think that people don't understand just how dramatic this decline has has been. And so there's latching onto things like the labor. Share of income has fallen, but less latching on to, you know, why are there fewer workers in the private sector organized now than there were before the National Labor Relations Act was passed? How is it that we've come to a place that it is if this law that protects workers saying I want to unionize with my coworkers is as if this law doesn't exist. Those types of stories of like you need to update your priors of like actually it's kind of closer to the 1920s. Like we don't really have union protection in the U.S. So those are those are two that I think are underappreciated. The third one is, and this might be on the more conservative side, but skews maybe skews liberal. The composition of who doesn't work, people don't understand it. They don't understand it. They don't have a sense for who is out of work, and what does that mean? Of you, you are under 65, and you are not participating in the labor market, who are you? I think it forces a lot of really uncomfortable questions about our society reflected back through our economy, as opposed to the other way around. People who don't work, you're going to have really disproportionate number of people who have a disability. People who are caregiving, and then people who are dealing with addiction, and how expensive caregiving is, how hard it is to be a disabled person in the U.S., and you know how addiction is treated in this country. Those are three really uncomfortable questions, and so I think the overarching conservative sentiment that people don't want to work and they're lazy and they just want to get on a public program, there is some truth behind it, but it's it's the diagnosis is wrong. We have a we have a lot of people who aren't working, and our labor force participation rates in the U.S. are are so much lower than our peer countries in Europe. We work less than them. We have fewer adults working than them, and I think that their instinct is right that we don't have as much adults working. But I think their their characterization is wrong, and the characterization that we need to be talking about gets at these really uncomfortable questions.
John Bailer
You know, a lot of what you're doing is relying on on data sources that you can get from the federal government and from you know, so BLS collects data. Lots of other you know, other sources are available to you. There have been some cuts in some of these programs in recent years. Are are you seeing that that kind of that you're you're missing some of the information that you'd like to have, or that it's it's starting to not be available for you to use to investigate some of these questions.
Kathryn Edwards
Well, yeah, we missed a month of data in in an absolutely unnecessary shutdown. You know, they could have written that shutdown. I'm sure all your listeners know this. They could have written it so data collection could have continued, but they didn't. Okay, you know I haven't had I haven't had an issue. I talked to people about this, and I think there's there's there's too many people that are involved in the production of U.S. statistics, at least the labor market statistics. There are there are federal laws governing the national economic indicators that offer a degree of protection on a lot of what I'm looking at that would you wouldn't necessarily get with like health data, environmental data, you know, data on pollution. Those they're kind of attacking because they don't have the same protection. But I mean, the Federal Reserve needs to know how many people are unemployed, and that they, you know, Congress has laws dictating how the national economic indicators are are produced. So I, I'm not worried about them being manipulated. I'm worried about them being underfunded, and that underfunding leading to mistakes, and then those mistakes being held up as why they're bad, right? And that we are. It is a self-fulfilling prophecy that I'm going to gut these agencies in terms of funding. You know, BLS's funding never recovered from sequestration in 2012, and so that that you're just setting up you're setting them up for failure and then pointing to their failure. So I worry more about that. I also worry that the statistical agencies need a champion in Congress. I don't know who that champion is. And so finding someone who can actually champion the statistical agencies is tough, and you should know that I I do talk to congressional staff, you know, all the time, and I get a lot of people who will reach out to me from so and so's office, and they want to talk about an issue, and I bring up stats every time, and I always say I can't do we can't do any of this if we don't have good statistics. Need to get you need to get the statistical agencies like just don't tell anybody just put it in there and don't say it's in the letter just like very quietly you know just be like oops funding went up for this stat how did that happen like it's not like it's that much money so I I advocate as much as I can for this but it has not affected my current is not affected my current ability to do data to do research. I suppose, outside of funding, I'm really worried about the census. The attacks on the census. I mean, I feel like they learned their lesson from the last administration, and now they have like sharpened their tools, and they are going after the Census Bureau, which doesn't have the same type of protection that the Bureau of Labor Statistics does. I mean, it's it's much more of, you know, an open target, because what kind of maniac would would attack the Census Bureau? So that that I I'm worried more about the Census Bureau and funding than I am about the quality of the current data I'm looking at.
Rosemary Pennington
Well, that's all the time we have for this episode of Stats and Stories. Thank you again for bein
John Bailer
Yeah, thanks, Kathryn.
Rosemary Pennington
Stats and Stories is a partnership between the American Statistical Association and Miami University's Departments of Statistics and Media, Journalism, and Film. You can follow us on Spotify, Apple Podcast, or other places where you find podcasts. If you'd like to share your thoughts on the program, send your email to statstories@amstat.org, or check us out@statsandstories.net. And be sure to listen for future editions of Stats and Stories, where we discuss the statistics behind the stories and the stories behind the statistics.
Double-click to edit...